149 Rue des Suisses Apartment Buildings

Competition: 1996
Project: 1997–1998
Realization: 1999–2000

Two distinct urban situations characterize the housing project in the 14^th arrondissement of Paris: on one hand, the blocks facing the Rue des Suisses and the Rue Jonquoy and on the other, the courtyard with high fire walls at the back (îlot).

Our two apartment buildings on Rue des Suisses and the Rue Jonquoy are incorporated in the frontage, typical of housing blocks in many Parisian arrondissements. Verticals characterize the overall design of the relatively homogeneous façades of the adjacent buildings. As in most Parisian quarters of the 19^th century, the street thus conveys certain elegance despite the fact that the individual buildings are not particularly attractive. Our two apartment buildings with their folded frontage and folding shutters fit seamlessly into the vertical arrangement of the frontage. The folding shutters can be adjusted individually by tenants so that, in spite of the targeted homogeneity of the façades, the overall impression of their appearance varies. As in the neighboring buildings, the flats are accessed via a central staircase, with a concierge checking the entrance on the Rue des Suisses.

The situation in the courtyard in the back was entirely different, because there were no predetermined urban specifications to use as a typological basis for the project. How should one go about planning the flats? What city-planning strategies should be pursued? What kind of buildings, what kind of architecture should be placed there?

We tried to realize a model for living that is relatively unusual in the centre of Paris, and that would attract an entirely different kind of tenant than the street-front buildings. Instead of competing with the towering fire walls, we settled on a horizontal strategy, that is, we kept the buildings low to ensure that as many flats as possible would be directly and intimately connected with the grounds and the garden.

An extended, three-story structure with arcade-like balconies forms the backbone of the complex in the interior of the block. Adjoining it are cottage-like, one-storey buildings for the kitchens and bathrooms. In front of the long garden wall that runs along a school playground, we built a few extra small, one-family homes with gabled roofs. The result looks like a seemingly random system of small units, courtyards and lanes with fragments of old and new walls covered with cultivated and wild vegetation.

This urban model comes as surprise when one enters the courtyard because it presents such a great contrast to the alignment of 19^th century blocks facing the street. But on taking a closer look, one discovers a few remnants of a still older, pre-Haussmann quarter, little streets like the Villa Mallebay, Villa Duthy or Villa Jamot, whose small scale and proportions are reflected in our buildings.

The living quarters in the different buildings and parts of buildings vary greatly in size, layout and placement, but all are designed with maximum daylight and interesting views of the landscaped courtyard.

The fair-faced concrete walls have been covered with a large, grid-like net of synthetic ropes to provide a growing base for climbing plants like ivy and wild grape vines. Wooden roller blinds along the three-storey façade run on molded metal tracks, giving the building a profile, like a piece of furniture.

Herzog & de Meuron, 2000

149_CP_0104_764_MS

Process

The two new buildings close off the perimeter of the block. The bend in the façade on Rue des Suisses guides one in. The various positions of the blinds enliven thee façade. The perforated folding blinds function like a curtain to provide privacy.

A long courtyard building extends behind the two new buildings. The courtyard façade of the narrow building facing Rue Jonquoy. Small concrete buildings adopt the scale of the former courtyard building. The courtyard becomes a garden; the façade has wires for climbing plants.

Two small concrete houses stand like pieces of furniture in the courtyard. Projecting extensions between the courtyard building and the partition wall. Plants grow on the back and short sides of the courtyard building. A garden in the middle of the city: courtyard with groups of trees.

Two small concrete hoses stand like pieces of furniture in the courtyard. Projecting extensions between the courtyard building and the partition wall. Plants grow on the back and short sides of the courtyard building. A garden in the middle of the city: courtyard with groups of trees.

Drawings

Team

Partners: Jacques Herzog; Pierre de Meuron; Christine Binswanger
Project Team: Sacha Marchal (Project Architect); Andrea Bernhard; Robert Hösl; Mario Meier; Reto Oechslin; Susanne Kleinlein; Stephan Wolff; Béla Berec

Facts

Client: Régie Immobilière de la Ville de Paris
Planning: Architect Planning: Herzog & de Meuron, Basel, Switzerland; Partner Architect: Cabinet A.S.Mizrahi, Paris, France; General Contractor: Bouygues SA, Paris, France
Building Data: Site Area: 29'428 sqft, 2'734 sqm; Gross floor area (GFA): 90'621 sqft, 8'419 sqm; Footprint: 14'843 sqft, 1'379 sqm; Height: 121 ft, 37 m
Links: www.rivp.fr

Bibliography

Gerhard Mack, Herzog & de Meuron: “Herzog & de Meuron 1992-1996. The Complete Works. Volume 3.” Edited by: Gerhard Mack. Chinese ed. Beijing, China Architecture & Building Press, 2010. Vol. No. 3.

Luis Fernández-Galiano (Ed.): “Arquitectura Viva. Herzog & de Meuron 1978-2007.” 2nd rev. ed. Madrid, Arquitectura Viva, 2007.

Fernando Márquez Cecilia, Richard Levene (Eds.): “El Croquis. Herzog & de Meuron 1981-2000. Between the Face and the Landscape. The Cunning of Cosmetics. Entre el Rostro y el Paisaje. La Astucia de la Cosmética.” 2nd adv. and rev. ed. Vol. No. 60+84, Madrid, El Croquis, 2005.

Nobuyuki Yoshida (Ed.): “Architecture and Urbanism. Herzog & de Meuron 1978-2002.” Tokyo, A+U Publishing Co., Ltd., 02.2002.

“Herzog & de Meuron. Natural History.” Edited by: Philip Ursprung. Exh. Cat. “Herzog & de Meuron. Archaeology of the Mind.” Canadian Centre for Architecture, Montreal. 23 October 2002 – 6 April 2003. 2nd ed. Baden, Lars Müller, 2005.

“Herzog & de Meuron. Naturgeschichte.” Edited by: Philip Ursprung. Exh. Cat. “Herzog & de Meuron. Archaeology of the Mind.” Canadian Centre for Architecture, Montreal. 23 October 2002 – 6 April 2003. 2nd ed. Baden, Lars Müller, 2005.

“Herzog & de Meuron. Histoire Naturelle.” Edited by: Philip Ursprung. Exh. Cat. “Herzog & de Meuron. Archaeology of the Mind.” Canadian Centre for Architecture, Montreal. 23 October 2002 – 6 April 2003. Baden, Lars Müller, 2002.

Fernando Márquez Cecilia, Richard Levene (Eds.): “El Croquis. Herzog & de Meuron 1998-2002. La Naturaleza del Artificio. The Nature of Artifice.” Vol. No. 109/110, Madrid, El Croquis, 2002.

Paolo Giardiello: “Interventi Urbani a Monaco e Parigi. Fünf Höfe, Monaco. Apartments Building, Rue des Suisses, Parigi.”
In: Marco Casamonti (Ed.). “Area. Rivista di Architettura e Arti del Progetto.” Vol. No. 61, Milan, Federico Motta editore spa, 03.2002. pp. 24-47.

Philippe Duboy: “Herzog & de Meuron. L’Hétérotopie à Paris. Rue des Suisses, XIVe Arrondissement.” In: Jean-Michel Place (Ed.). “L’Architecture d’Aujourd’hui.” Vol. No. 337, Paris, L’Architecture d’Aujourd’hui, 11.2001. pp. 112-117.

Herzog & de Meuron: “Gramática Urbana. Viviendas en la Rue des Suisses, Paris.” In: Luis Fernández-Galiano (Ed.). “Arquitectura Viva.” Cohabitación Europea. Vol. No. 81, Madrid, Arquitectura Viva SL, 11.2001. pp. 34-39.

Wilfried Wang: “Herzog & de Meuron.” 3rd adv. and rev. ed. Basel / Boston / Berlin, Birkhäuser, 1998. (= Studiopaperback).